The Butcher's Boy

 The Butcher’s Boy by Thomas Perry, a very prolific writer, published his first novel in 1982, and he won an Edgar Award for it. Although I listened to this audiobook to the end, I thought the best part was the introduction, I’m guessing it was written in the early 2000s, by Michael Connelly. He wrote about struggling with people who were complimenting his own writing only to have someone say they still liked his first book the best (The Black Echo published in 1992).  Connelly wrote this introduction at a time when Connelly had already written 12 books, so he lamented that such a back-handed compliment meant his time since the first publication must have been time squandered. He described feeling some difficulty with his feeling that The Butcher’s Boy was also Perry’s best work. Connelly added that his own reaction to such a compliment did eventually change and he was able to respond more kindly to those compliments. (I’ve read The Black Echo several times, and while I think it was a very good story, Connelly is the master of this genre, and he has in fact written more and better works.)

My primary problem with this audiobook was the narrator. The man spoke in too slow a cadence and there was a slight slur to his words, as if he was a bit drunk. The story itself was quite solid as you might guess given its history of winning the Edgar, but I think the novel would be better received by reading it and not just listening. I’m not really motivated to read the second book in the series, at least not in the audiobook format with the same narrator. The reviews of the four-book series have been quite favorable.