Unfortunately, the subject matter of this first case is the murder of a mother who has unspeakably abused her two children. In the present day, these two children return to Gamache's life in Three Pines. The author does a fine job connecting the timelines through a real life event in Montreal history, but the second half of the novel turns into something everyone has read before.
Ms. Penny has written Inspector Gamache novels in a variety of styles - some are very cerebral, some thrillers, some a nice mix. In this latest mystery, she indulges several tropes her readers have appreciated her avoiding all these years. The elaborate revenge of the enemy from the past is the most egregious, but there are others to be discovered upon reading.
I love Louise Penny a great deal and her previous novels have truly meant something to me on a personal level. My recommendation is always to start at the beginning of a series, but I think it's essential in this case so one doesn't mistake Inspector Gamache as just another detective. Because he truly is unique.
As you may know, Amazon Prime has brought Inspector Gamache to life as played by Alfred Molina. Three Pines, named for the village central to many of the novels, is an excellent adaptation of the early entries in the series. If you haven't read Louise Penny, start with Still Life and you will become part of the Three Pines family. If you are a fan, I'm afraid you may be disappointed in this latest installment. That said, she has built up so much good will I'll read the next one the day it is released.
Curt Remarks
(new MRB contributor as of 1/2023)
No comments:
Post a Comment