Tom Lake is the 13th novel by Ann Patchett, an award winning novelist. The audiobook format is narrated by none other than Meryl Streep. The only other Patchett novel reviewed in this blog was The Dutch House and that audiobook was narrated by Tom Hanks. While I was knocked out by The Dutch House, Tom Lake did not move me nearly as much. Given that this is a blog mostly of action, mystery, murder, and espionage, I think this book belongs more in a women’s book club that in this blog. There were no murders in Tom Lake. (The lake named for the rich offspring of the ultra wealthy family which once owned the property surrounding the lake in Northern Michigan.)
The novel mostly took place on the cherry farm of Lara and Joe Nelson, as well as their three daughters. As a high school student, Lara had performed the role of Emily in Our Town. Subsequently, she did the role again two more times, and it was the last time in a summer stock community theater in Michigan that she performed opposite an incredibly handsome man, Peter Duke, who did go on to become a television and movie star. That summer, she fell in love Duke, and she was also spotted by a Hollywood movie director who put Lara in his latest film. There were delays in the release of the movie and Lara ended up staying in Hollywood for several years during which time she did get some roles. Apparently, while being fabulous in the role of Emily, her skills as an actor were limited, and her life as an actor came to an end. She returned to her home in New Hampshire while trying to figure out what to do with her life.
Later, she ran into Joe Nelson who had been the director of the community theater version of Our Town, and they fell in love. Joe’s family was in the cherry business and he loved that life. Both Lara and Joe had left the theater and had no desire to return. The story took place in 2020, the first year of the pandemic, and the usual number of summer workers who came to the farm to help pick cherries did not show up. The three girls returned to the family home to help with the cherry harvest, and it was then that they pried out their mother’s life story. The girls, especially the oldest named Emily, were fixated on the idea that their mom could have been a star, could have been married to Duke, and could have been a famous person.
The writing was beautiful and clever as Lara narrated her own experience and told the story to her daughters, filling in details for the readers, not all of which she revealed to her daughters. It’s really a wonderful story about family dynamics and the success of a very functional family. But, given the content of the story compared to the usual genre of this blog, I cannot give it a strong recommendation for anyone who is looking for an adventure book. By the way, Meryl Streep was fabulous as the narrator.