I listened to Ms. Ware’s The Woman in Cabin 10 in audiobook format. (I’ve found by reading one novel and listening to an audiobook while I take long dog walks, I can have two stories going at the same time.) I previously reviewed The It Girl which was read by the very talented Imogen Church, and it was published in 2022. Once again Ms. Church was the reader of this earlier novel, written in 2016. Apparently, this novel was the author’s biggest seller and it received a 4/5 star rating on Amazon, a rating I consider to be generous.
I am not as thrilled with this novel as I was with The It Girl, although it is at least an average book. In The Woman in Cabin 10, Lo Blacklock writes for Velocity, a travel magazine. She has been employed there for 10 years, but as her employer is about to take pregnancy leave, Lo is given the change to travel on a new luxurious yacht. Despite turmoil in her personal life, she takes this assignment although she knows it might be the end of her relationship with a man who desperately loves her. This is a woman with a long history of panic attacks, and just before her departure on the ship, The Aurora, her apartment was burgled while she was there. She was slightly injured in the process. Her anxiety was heightened as she struggled to get herself organized in preparation for the trip.
On the first night at sea as she prepared for an upscale dinner and the chance to make contact with the well-heeled passengers on board the 10-suite cruise ship, she realized she had not brought her mascara. She knocked on the door of Cabin 10 where she encountered an unpleasant rude woman who gave her some mascara just to get rid of her. However, that woman did not make the gathering for dinner. Back in her cabin after the meal, and after having consumed a massive amount of alcohol, she heard a yell and a loud splash. She thought somebody had gone overboard from Cabin 10, but when she reported that, she was told none of the passengers or crew members were missing. She was also told that the person who had been supposed to be in Cabin 10 had cancelled the trip due to personal reasons. Lo began to doubt what she had seen and heard.
The Aurora’s planned course of travel was to go north in order to experience the aurora borealis, something the owner of the boat said everyone should see at least once in their lifetimes. The plot advances as Lo begins to suspect that others are conspiring against her to cover up a murder, and the plot plays out from there.
As a constant reader of mysteries and thrillers, I’m aware that I must often be willing to suspend my own reality testing, and I typically have no difficulty following an author into highly improbable scenarios. However, Ms. Ware’s pursuit of this particular plot was so unlikely, I began to laugh at the events that occurred. I simply could not accept the ending as being anything short of absurd. Furthermore, the author used language that was excessively superlative and hysterical (as in anxiety, not comedy). I thought Ms. Ware did nicely tidy up the issue of her protagonist’s personal troubles, but the resolution of the murder mysteries in this story ended with an even more improbable conclusion. I cannot give this book a good recommendation.