
This was not an easy read. The details were sometimes
hour-by-hour and White House or Pentagon meeting-by-meeting, and Woodward’s
writing frequently included lots of specific quotes of who said what to whom.
He analyzed the impact of nearly every personality on the decision making
process. So, it was sometimes a bit tedious for someone like me who is more
used to reading fiction. But, this is an important work, and regardless of your
opinion on the upcoming election, it will give you some insight into Obama and
his decision making process that you might not get anywhere else.
The book supported my own opinion of just how stupid it was
for George Bush to go into Afghanistan in the first place. Then, after Bush
invaded Iraq, his neglect of the war effort in Afghanistan was staggering.
Obama inherited a quagmire from which there can be no clean exit. Furthermore,
the book solidified my understanding of the complications of international
politics that involved not only the rivalry of Afghanistan and Pakistan, but
also the importance of Pakistan’s mistrust and hatred of India. If the U.S. was
seen to do too much for India, then Pakistan got more restrictive of what it
would allow the U.S. to do on their soil. The leaders of both Afghanistan and
Pakistan were not favorably portrayed. I also came away from the book with
admiration for our military and the tasks they have, but also a heightened
wariness of the military’s sense of entitlement to unlimited resources and
resentment towards anyone (i.e., Congress or the Executive Branch) who would
curtail or deny them anything they want. We Americans are fortunate that the
civilians have the ultimate control over the use of our military, because the
military people are insatiable, and they see no need to limit their efforts to
force decisions the way they want them to go, even if it means presenting
evidence to the president that is intentionally slanted and misleading.
Woodward ended the book with details from a 75-minute
discussion that he had with Obama in July 2010. The book definitely gets my
recommendation, with the caveat that it’s not an easy read.